The New York Giants declined Evan Neal’s fifth-year option but plan to give him an opportunity to redeem himself in 2025 by moving him to a new position. According to Paul Schwartz of the New York Post (via Pro Football Talk’s Charean Williams), Neal will battle Greg Van Roten and Aaron Stinnie for the starting right guard spot after primarily playing right tackle throughout his career.
Williams pointed out that Neal hasn’t lined up at guard since his freshman year at Alabama in 2019. He shifted to right tackle as a sophomore and then to left tackle in 2021. Now, as he transitions back to the interior line, Neal is aiming to deliver a solid season that could boost his value ahead of free agency—whether that future lies with the Giants or elsewhere.
By declining his fifth-year option, the Giants effectively cost Evan Neal a guaranteed $16.7 million payday. Instead, the offensive lineman will enter the 2025 campaign playing out the final year of his rookie contract, with his long-term NFL future hanging in the balance.
Evan Neal’s hoping his position change would bode well for him and the Giants
While Evan Neal’s NFL journey hasn’t unfolded as planned, the position switch could give him the fresh start he needs. Just last year, Mekhi Becton made a similar move from tackle to guard with the Eagles, reigniting his career and ultimately cashing in with a $20 million deal from the Chargers this offseason.
The road back won’t be smooth, but the Giants have a shot at redemption after a brutal 3-14 finish in 2024. A turnaround is sorely needed, though the climb will be steep in a loaded NFC East. The division looks even tougher in 2025, with both the Eagles and Commanders fresh off appearances in the NFC title game.
Russell Wilson is set to lead the Giants under center in 2025, and the future Hall of Famer steps into a lineup with plenty of potential. He’ll be throwing to Pro Bowl wideout Malik Nabers, handing off to rising talent Tyrone Tracy Jr., and sharing the backfield with the newly signed Cam Skattebo.
The Giants’ ground game could take a significant step forward if Evan Neal finally delivers on his potential. Though the 24-year-old has consistently had issues in pass protection, his strength as a run blocker stands out. That’s likely why the Giants are giving him a shot at guard. With just one year left on his rookie contract, Neal faces a make-or-break season to prove he belongs.
