The New Orleans Saints enter the 2025 NFL season under scrutiny, with experts labeling their quarterback room as the league’s worst. Following Derek Carr’s unexpected retirement, the team faces a significant challenge in fielding a competent offense amid a transitional phase.
The current trio of Tyler Shough, Jake Haener, and Spencer Rattler has drawn harsh criticism, with analysts doubting their readiness to lead. Shough, a rookie expected to step in as the starter, brings potential but lacks refinement. Haener and Rattler, both of whom struggled in limited action last season, provide little confidence as reliable backups. This group suffered a crippling blow with Carr’s departure, leaving New Orleans scrambling for stability.
Head coach Kellen Moore, in his first year at the helm, is tasked with navigating this uphill battle. Training camp has focused on developing young talent and re-establishing the team’s core values. Moore’s approach includes rotating quarterback reps and leaning on a leadership council of veterans to guide the process. However, the lack of proven talent at the most critical position casts a shadow over the team’s immediate prospects.
Beyond the quarterback struggles, New Orleans faces salary cap constraints and a roster lacking depth. With $82.7 million in dead cap space and limited flexibility, the team’s ability to make impactful moves is restricted. Rebuilding while balancing financial realities adds another layer of complexity to the organization’s efforts to remain competitive.
NFL Analysis Names New Orleans Saints’ Quarterback Room as the Worst Ahead of 2025 Season
New Orleans’ QB room has been assessed as the weakest in the league ahead of the 2025 season. This is detailed more in an analysis by Alex Kay for Bleacher Report.
Quarterbacks: Tyler Shough (starter), Spencer Rattler, Jake Haener, Hunter Dekkers
The New Orleans Saints had one of the league’s weaker quarterback rooms at the onset of the offseason, but this group suffered a crippling blow when incumbent starter Derek Carr blindsided the club with a retirement announcement in early May.
Carr wasn’t a star QB in the final years of his career by any means, but he was a serviceable veteran who finished a 27-game stint in the Big Easy with a winning record and tallied far more passing touchdowns (40) than interceptions (13) despite working with a limited supporting cast.
With the four-time Pro Bowler out of the picture, the Saints are facing an uphill battle to contend in their first season under new head coach Kellen Moore.
New Orleans’ success this season largely hinges on Shough’s ability to adapt quickly and exceed expectations. If the rookie falters, the team could find itself in contention for a top draft pick rather than a playoff berth. While the road ahead is daunting, the Saints are committed to laying the groundwork for future success.
As the team prepares for the 2025 campaign, the focus remains on growth and resilience. Whether or not the Saints can overcome these challenges, this season will serve as a critical turning point in their rebuilding journey.
For More Of My Content
For More Of My Content Follow me on Twitter at @BeatKit22. You may also reach out to me personally at kitguinhawa@gmail.com. To read more of our articles and keep up to date on the latest in college and NFL news, click here!
