Patrick Mahomes, one of the NFL’s most decorated quarterbacks, has sparked debate after being left out of the prestigious Madden 99 Club for the first time in four years. With a rating of 98 in Madden NFL 26, opinions have flooded in from fans and analysts, including former NFL star Chad Johnson, who offered his perspective on the decision.
Johnson, now overseeing Madden player ratings, addressed the backlash from Chiefs fans who felt Mahomes deserved a 99 rating. He explained that the rating reflects Mahomes’ 2024 performance, which, while impressive, fell short of his usual dominance.

Mahomes threw for under 4,000 yards last season, a statistic that Johnson cited as a key factor in the decision. Despite the uproar, Johnson emphasized that a 98 rating is still an elite mark, highlighting Mahomes’ status as one of the game’s top quarterbacks.
He noted that Mahomes’ career accomplishments, including two MVP awards and three Super Bowl titles, solidify his legacy regardless of video game rankings. Johnson’s take seemed to resonate with some fans, who acknowledged that the rating is fair given last season’s results.
Former NFL Star Chad Johnson Comments on Kansas City Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes’ Madden Rating

Former NFL star and current sports analyst Chad Johnson shared his thoughts about Mahomes’ Madden rating. This can be seen in a video shared by First Take on Instagram.
View this post on Instagram
“@ochocinco says 98 overall is a “fair” Madden rating for Patrick Mahomes 😯” First Take posted.
The Chiefs’ fan base, however, remains divided. Many argue that Mahomes’ impact on the field transcends statistics, making him worthy of a 99 rating every year. Others see the slight drop as motivation for the quarterback to elevate his game in the upcoming season, potentially earning the coveted 99 status later.

As the Madden 26 ratings continue to generate buzz, Mahomes’ exclusion from the 99 Club adds an intriguing storyline to the season. Whether the rating reflects a temporary dip or a new standard remains to be seen. For now, Mahomes will aim to prove that his greatness is undeniable, both on the field and in the virtual world.

For More Of My Content
For More Of My Content Follow me on Twitter at @BeatKit22. You may also reach out to me personally at kitguinhawa@gmail.com. To read more of our articles and keep up to date on the latest in college and NFL news, click here!