Gridiron Heroics
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Trending
    • Pac-12 Media Deal Extended with CBS Sports Through 2030-31 Season
    • ‘Mourning The Passing’: Las Vegas Raiders Release Statement After Former Player Died
    • Breaking: Bengals’ QB Joe Burrow Finally Reveals His Girlfriend’s Identity (Report)
    • Fans React to Chiefs’ Heartwarming Gesture in Final Day of Minicamp
    • “The George Pickens Hype Is Understandable”: NFL Insider Claims Dallas Cowboys Trading For George Pickens Will Pay Off For Them In 2025 (Report)
    • “The Ravens Did Extensive Work”: Baltimore Ravens Biggest Story Entering 2025 Season Is Life Without Justin Tucker At Kicker
    • “The Coaching Staff Was In Full Force”: Detroit Lions Insider Reveals Team Will Be Fine With Dan Campbell Despite Two Key Coordinators Leaving In Offseason
    • “Sayin Is The Most Polished Quarterback On The Roster”: College Football Insider Lists Ohio State Buckeyes Quarterback Julian Sayin As Potential Breakout Star In 2025
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Our Writers
    • Write for Gridiron Heroics
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Gridiron Heroics
    SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES
    • NFL
      • AFC East
        • AFC East
        • Buffalo Bills
        • Miami Dolphins
        • New England Patriots
        • New York Jets
      • AFC North
        • Baltimore Ravens
        • Cincinnati Bengals
        • Cleveland Browns
        • Pittsburgh Steelers
      • AFC South
        • Houston Texans
        • Indianapolis Colts
        • Jacksonville Jaguars
        • Tennessee Titans
      • AFC West
        • Denver Broncos
        • Kansas City Chiefs
        • Las Vegas Raiders
        • Los Angeles Chargers
      • NFC East
        • Dallas Cowboys
        • New York Giants
        • Philadelphia Eagles
        • Washington Commanders
      • NFC North
        • Chicago Bears
        • Detroit Lions
        • Green Bay Packers
        • Minnesota Vikings
      • NFC South
        • Atlanta Falcons
        • Carolina Panthers
        • New Orleans Saints
        • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
      • NFC West
        • Arizona Cardinals
        • Los Angeles Rams
        • San Francisco 49ers
        • Seattle Seahawks
    • Fantasy Football
    • College Football
    • NFL Draft
    • PODCAST
    Gridiron Heroics
    Home»NFL»AFC East»Catastrophe involving the Indianapolis Colts: Worst Play in NFL History
    AFC East

    Catastrophe involving the Indianapolis Colts: Worst Play in NFL History

    Kevin PerryBy Kevin PerryOctober 18, 2022Updated:April 2, 2023No Comments4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Indianapolis Colts Catastrophe
    The Patriots weren’t fooled by the Colts’ peculiar formation on fourth down. (Barry Chin / The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    On this day in 2015, the Indianapolis Colts attempted the wildest play in football history. On Sunday Night Football, the Indianapolis Colts were trailing the New England Patriots 27-21 with 1:14 to go in the third quarter. Andrew Luck failed to convert a 3rd and 3 to Donte Moncrief so the Colts brought out Pat McAfee to punt.

    The Indianapolis Colts Catastrophe

    What happened next will go down in the annals of football history. The Colts pulled everybody to the right side of the field and Griff Whelan lined up at center Colt Anderson who was the “quarterback”. With the Colts trying to trick the Patriots and draw them offsides the ball was snapped.

    Jonathan Bostic, Brandon Bolden, Nate Ebner, and Logan Ryan all collapsed on Griff Whelan for the sack and a turnover on downs. For many questioning why the ball was snapped and or why even try this illegal formation don’t worry we have answers.

    https://twitter.com/ClayTravis/status/1582360753121955842?s=20&t=N_R57P2a7da_IAftr551og

    The Plan

    First off, the Colts planned for this if they were to be inside their own half of the field. The plan was to draw the Patriots into a substitution penalty and get a five yard penalty and a first down. By running towards their sidelines, the Colts, wanted to make it seem like they were bringing their offense back onto the field. By having Whelan under center he could snap the ball and take a knee if they Patriots had too many men on the field, thus giving Indianapolis a first down.

    If that’s not the case then there is really no difference in five yards with a delay of game penalty when most likely the ball will be a fair catch inside of the twenty yard line on a punt. So by the Colts were trying to catch the Patriots sleeping. Not a big deal as well with All Pro Punter Pat McAfee booting the ball away.

    Colt Anderson never stood a chance once the ball was snapped. (Barry Chin / The Boston Globe via Getty Images)
    Colt Anderson never stood a chance once the ball was snapped. (Barry Chin / The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

    Secondly, the left gunner who practice the play all week for the Colts fell ill the day before the games. Ultimately, Griff Whelan was chosen to be the left gunner on the punt unit so he was the one responsible for snapping the ball for the substitution penalty. Whelan was a swiss army knife for the Colts so he was trusted by the coaching staff to snap the ball. Unfortunately, the plan didn’t work out because Whelan never practiced the play. He was aware of the play but didn’t know any of the nuance of it. This led to the confusion that is now know and the worst play in football history.

    Media Perception

    The play would be looked at and analyzed many time by NBC’s Cris Collinsworth and Al Micheals for the next five to ten minutes of air time. The play would also lead to the touchdown by LeGarrette Blount which would ultimately be the game winning score.

    Pat McAfee speaks on his podcast about how the breakdown of the play but also how successful it was in practice. He talks about how they kept having the scout team caught in the middle of substitutions and how this play would work. Sadly, this was not the case at all in the game. Twitter also had a field day with this play as well.

    Football is an interesting game. No two plays are ever the same. Even if you call the same play multiple times in a game it is unlikely that everything will happen like it did prior. In this case, this will be the only time that we will have the chance to see a play unfold like this. A plan that was set up to catch the Patriots off guard was actually a ticking time bomb for the Colts. Follow @kperry2217 on Twitter for more football history.

    Get the latest Pro and College Football news, analysis, and breaking stories on the NFL, NCAA, Fantasy Football, and more! Tap the star to add us to your favorites on Google News, so you never miss a story from the football field.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Avatar photo
    Kevin Perry

    Kevin Perry is a 2021 Graduate of Fitchburg State University. He has written for The Boston Globe, Patriot Ledger, Providence Journal, and Sentinel Enterprise. He has covered the Patriots for the past 3 seasons as well as NHL/ College Hockey and EUFA soccer.

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    College Football

    Pac-12 Media Deal Extended with CBS Sports Through 2030-31 Season

    By Vincent PensabeneJune 23, 20250
    AFC West

    ‘Mourning The Passing’: Las Vegas Raiders Release Statement After Former Player Died

    By Jordan SiglerJune 23, 20250
    AFC North

    Breaking: Bengals’ QB Joe Burrow Finally Reveals His Girlfriend’s Identity (Report)

    By McQuade ArnoldJune 23, 20250
    Kansas City Chiefs

    Fans React to Chiefs’ Heartwarming Gesture in Final Day of Minicamp

    By Angelo GuinhawaJune 23, 20250
    Gridiron Heroics Writers
    Follow Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    READ MORE
    2024 NFL Draft Aaron Rodgers Baltimore Ravens Bill Belichick Buffalo Bills Caleb Williams Chicago Bears Chiefs Cincinnati Bengals Cleveland Browns College Football Cowboys Dak Prescott Dallas Cowboys Denver Broncos Deshaun Watson Detroit Lions Donald Trump Football Green Bay Packers Joe Burrow Josh Allen Justin Fields Kansas City Chiefs Las Vegas Raiders Miami Dolphins Minnesota Vikings New England Patriots New Orleans Saints New York Giants New York Jets NFL NFL Draft nfl news NFL Rumors Patrick Mahomes Philadelphia Eagles Pittsburgh Steelers Russell Wilson San Francisco 49ers shedeur sanders Taylor Swift Tom Brady Travis Kelce Washington Commanders
    Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Editorial Process
    • Contact Us
    • Corporate
    © 2025 Gridiron Heroics.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.