College football is a sport that inspires intense passion and loyalty among fans. While many coaches are revered as heroes, others have become villains in the eyes of the public, whether due to their actions, personalities, or controversial decisions. Let’s explore 10 college football coaches who have been vilified, examining the reasons behind their negative reputations and the impact on their careers and the sport.
The Most Vilified College Football Coaches Imaginable
1. Urban Meyer
Urban Meyer’s coaching career has been marked by both incredible success and significant controversy. While his on-field achievements at Florida and Ohio State are undeniable, Meyer has been criticized for his handling of player discipline issues and the culture he created within his programs.
The most damaging incident occurred at Ohio State, where Meyer was accused of mishandling domestic violence allegations against assistant coach Zach Smith. This controversy led to Meyer’s suspension and eventual retirement from Ohio State. His brief and tumultuous tenure as head coach of the NFL’s Jacksonville Jaguars further tarnished his reputation.
Meyer’s win-at-all-costs mentality and perceived lack of accountability have made him a polarizing figure in college football.
2. Bobby Petrino
Bobby Petrino’s coaching ability has never been in question, but his personal conduct and lack of loyalty have made him one of the most vilified coaches in recent memory. Petrino’s abrupt departure from the Atlanta Falcons to take the Arkansas job mid-season in 2007 was widely criticized.
However, it was his actions at Arkansas that truly cemented his villain status. In 2012, Petrino was involved in a motorcycle accident with a female staff member with whom he was having an extramarital affair. The subsequent cover-up attempt and revelation of his actions led to his firing and a significant hit to his reputation.
Petrino’s career has been marked by sudden departures and ethical lapses, making him a frequent target of criticism in the college football world.
3. Lane Kiffin
Lane Kiffin’s brash personality and nomadic coaching career have made him a controversial figure in college football. His one-year tenure at Tennessee, which ended with his abrupt departure to USC, earned him the ire of Volunteers fans.
Kiffin’s time at USC was marked by NCAA sanctions (stemming from the Pete Carroll era) and underwhelming on-field results, leading to his infamous firing on the tarmac after a game. His stint as offensive coordinator at Alabama under Nick Saban was successful but not without controversy, as his relationship with the legendary coach appeared strained at times.
While Kiffin has found success at FAU and Ole Miss, his past actions and outspoken nature continue to make him a polarizing figure in college football, especially as he’s bounced around between SEC rivals.
4. Art Briles
Art Briles’ fall from grace at Baylor University is one of the most dramatic in college football history. Under Briles, Baylor’s football program reached unprecedented heights, but it came at a terrible cost.
In 2016, Briles was fired amid a sexual assault scandal involving numerous Baylor football players. An investigation found that Briles and his staff had failed to report allegations of sexual assault and had interfered with investigations. The scandal revealed a culture of prioritizing football success over student safety and ethical conduct.
Briles’ attempts to return to coaching have been met with widespread criticism, and he remains one of the most vilified figures in college football.
5. Hugh Freeze
Hugh Freeze’s tenure at Ole Miss was marked by on-field success and off-field controversy. Under Freeze, Ole Miss achieved victories over Alabama and reached major bowl games. However, an NCAA investigation revealed numerous recruiting violations and a lack of institutional control.
Freeze resigned in 2017 after it was discovered he had made calls to escort services using his university-issued phone. This personal scandal, combined with the NCAA violations, severely damaged Freeze’s reputation.
While Freeze has since returned to coaching at Liberty and Auburn, his past actions continue to make him a controversial figure in college football.
6. Jim Harbaugh
Jim Harbaugh’s vilification stems from his personality and coaching style, but we can’t ignore his recently condemned scandal. Known for his intense, sometimes abrasive demeanor, Harbaugh has clashed with opposing coaches, media members, and even his own administration at Michigan.
Harbaugh’s inability to beat Ohio State for several years and his team’s struggles in big games led to criticism from Michigan fans and national media alike. Harbaugh’s recruiting tactics and outspoken nature have also drawn the ire of rival coaches and fans.
While Harbaugh has found more success in recent years including a current sting in the NFL, he remains a polarizing figure in the sport.
7. Rick Neuheisel
Rick Neuheisel’s coaching career was marked by success on the field and controversy off it. At Colorado and Washington, Neuheisel ran afoul of NCAA rules, with both programs facing sanctions after his departure.
Neuheisel’s tenure at Washington ended in particularly controversial fashion when he was fired for participating in a high-stakes basketball betting pool. This incident, combined with previous NCAA issues, severely damaged Neuheisel’s reputation in college football circles.
While Neuheisel has since rebuilt his image somewhat as a television analyst, his coaching career remains tainted by these controversies.
8. Charlie Weis
Charlie Weis became a vilified figure not so much for any ethical lapses but for his perceived arrogance and failure to live up to expectations. After initial success at Notre Dame, Weis’s teams underperformed, leading to his firing in 2009.
What truly cemented Weis’s villain status was the massive buyout he received from Notre Dame, reportedly around $19 million. This payout, combined with his subsequent failure at Kansas, made Weis a symbol of coaching excess and mismanagement in college football.
9. Mike Leach
Mike Leach’s innovative offensive schemes have made him a successful coach, but his outspoken and sometimes controversial personality has also made him a polarizing figure. Leach’s tenure at Texas Tech ended in controversy when he was accused of mistreating a player with a concussion, Adam James.
Throughout his career, Leach has made headlines for his unusual press conference rants and off-the-cuff remarks. While some find his personality entertaining, others view him as unprofessional and problematic.
Leach’s unconventional approach and willingness to court controversy have made him a divisive figure in college football.
10. Nick Saban
Nick Saban’s inclusion on this list may be surprising given his unprecedented success at Alabama, but his vilification stems from that very dominance. Saban’s Alabama teams became so successful that they’ve become the team many fans love to hate, not dissimilar to the former Patriots Coach Bill Belichick.
Saban’s perceived joylessness, his intense focus on “The Process,” and his teams’ relentless winning have made him a villain in the eyes of many college football fans outside of Alabama. His abrupt departure from the Miami Dolphins to take the Alabama job also earned him criticism.
While respected for his coaching acumen—even making our list of most iconic college football coaches of all time— Saban’s dominance and businesslike approach to the game have made him a target for those who resent Alabama’s success.
Conclusion
These ten college football coaches have become vilified figures for various reasons, ranging from ethical lapses and NCAA violations to personality conflicts and on-field dominance. Their stories serve as cautionary tales about the pressures and pitfalls of high-level college football coaching.
It’s worth noting that public perception can change over time, and some of these coaches have worked to rehabilitate their images. Others continue to be successful despite their controversial reputations. The vilification of these coaches also reflects broader issues in college football, including the intense pressure to win, the commercialization of the sport, and the challenges of maintaining ethical standards in a high-stakes environment.
