New Orleans Saints rookie quarterback Tyler Shough has quickly earned significant praise following his standout performances during the team’s organized team activities. Selected in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft, Shough has already positioned himself as a strong contender for the starting role in Week 1.
Reports from OTAs detail Shough’s ability to make impressive throws, including two 60-yard completions that highlighted his arm strength and accuracy. Observers noted his poise and ability to command the offense, a promising sign for a rookie adjusting to the NFL level. Despite a few mistakes, including an interception during drills, his overall performance has been described as a strong foundation to build upon.

Shough is competing against second-year quarterback Spencer Rattler, but early signs suggest the rookie may have the edge. His consistent play and natural leadership have been noted as key factors in his potential to secure the starting position. As New Orleans transitions into a new era following Derek Carr’s retirement, Shough’s emergence could provide stability at a crucial position.
Coaches and analysts have also praised Shough’s maturity and readiness, which stem from his extensive college experience. At 26 years old, he brings a level of composure uncommon for most rookies, giving him a unique advantage in adapting to the professional game. His ability to stretch the field with deep throws has already caught the attention of teammates and coaches alike.
New Orleans Saints’ Tyler Shough Receives Big Boos After NFL OTAs

As it stands, Shough’s performance at the OTAs has worked out well for him. This is detailed more in an analysis by Brent Sobreski for Bleacher Report.
Tyler Shough won’t be handed the New Orleans Saints’ starting quarterback job, but he’s one step removed from that point.
With Derek Carr’s retirement, Spencer Rattler’s performance during his rookie season (under a different coaching staff) and a Jake Haener injury at the start of OTAs, this year’s 40th overall draft pick is positioned well to be a Day 1 starter. His early returns certainly haven’t hurt the rookie’s standing.
“The rookie can absolutely spin it,” Luke Johnson of NOLA.com wrote after attending the Saints’ organized team activities.
While the final decision on the starting quarterback will likely come during training camp, Shough’s early success has created excitement around his potential. His ability to perform under pressure and refine his game will be critical as the Saints prepare for the season.

Shough’s strong start has provided hope for New Orleans and their fans, signaling a bright future for their offense. As he continues to develop, the rookie could solidify himself as the centerpiece of New Orleans’ next chapter.

For More Of My Content
For More Of My Content Follow me on Twitter at @BeatKit22. You may also reach out to me personally at kitguinhawa@gmail.com. To read more of our articles and keep up to date on the latest in college and NFL news, click here!