The 3rd-ranked Miami Hurricanes traveled to Doak S. Campbell Stadium to play against the 18th-ranked Florida State Seminoles, winning 28-22 and soaring to 5-0. Carson Beck and the Hurricanes’ receiving corps dominated the 40th-ranked passing defense in the nation. Beck completed 20 of 27 pass attempts for 241 yards and four touchdowns.
Highlighting one of the biggest stars of the game was a player who should be in high school.
Miami Hurricanes’ three-star recruit steals the show

Malachi Toney dominated the Seminoles’ secondary, leading the team with seven receptions for 107 yards and two touchdowns, showcasing his elite speed, route-running ability, and explosiveness after the catch. His first touchdown occurred on a 44-yard flea-flicker, where he caught a deep ball, got past the defender, and sprinted into the end zone. On Toney’s second touchdown, he displayed his dangerous after-the-catch ability by turning a four-yard pass into a 40-yard house call, thanks to a nasty juke to evade a defender.
CARSON BECK 44-YARD FLEA FLICKER TO 17-YEAR-OLD MALACHI TONEY 🪄 pic.twitter.com/u4MbEGzmOA
— ESPN (@espn) October 5, 2025
MALACHI TONEY RUNS IT IN AGAIN 😤
Watch Miami-Florida State on ABC and the ESPN App pic.twitter.com/DVDLKmQS6V
— ESPN (@espn) October 5, 2025
The craziest part is that, technically, he should not be playing at this level yet.
Miami Hurricanes’ star should be in high school (technically)

Fans react to the freshman’s explosion

Play was called back but Malachi Toney is possibly a generational player.
This guy is 17 years old and reclassified to play this season. Give this kid 3 more seasons and watch out.
Tremendous athleticism.
pic.twitter.com/soxl1Od9vZ— Garrett Armbrust (@4thandsaturday) October 5, 2025
I understand the Malachi Toney Tyreek Hill comparisons
— LC (@laurencowling) October 5, 2025
Malachi Toney the truth
— $Ⓜ️K (@coachquiis) October 5, 2025
Malachi Toney reclassify is crazy because he’s a child balling out like that. Reminds me of Ryan Williams last year
— Raiders Stress Me Out ✈️ (@cardeaframez) October 5, 2025
Malachi Toney is special
— Don (@DonDrakey) October 5, 2025
Malachi Toney is like Tyreek Hill 2.0, kid is gonna be special
— ໊ (@PapiGing) October 5, 2025
Malachi Toney could take snaps in the league tomorrow and look good doing it.
Sheesh.
— Ghost of Adam Gase (@GhostOfAdamGase) October 5, 2025
Sonic the hedgehog type speed!
— Rip (@Ripmeta_X) October 5, 2025
Btw he just turned 18 two weeks ago
— Kéndo ⬛️🟥 (@kendo1804_) October 5, 2025
He’s a dawgggggg
— C-John (@Cjohn_getitdone) October 5, 2025
star
— CanesMuse (@canes_muse) October 5, 2025
And he should be a senior in HS still
— ChiTiger33 (@ChiTiger330) October 5, 2025
cannot believe this guy just turned 18. his speed was beyond every other player on that field tonight.
— 3% chance of making finals (@cloudblowr69) October 5, 2025
Best 3 star I have seen…
— William Stet (@stet770773) October 5, 2025
He will be another legend from #TheU
— xIA (@mattxia) October 5, 2025
He’s getting the Ryan Williams media treatment but he’s better
— Brad Senderling (@bsenderling14) October 5, 2025

