Justin Herbert enters the 2025 NFL season under scrutiny, with analysts pointing to his lack of big-game experience as a significant concern. While the Los Angeles Chargers quarterback has displayed immense talent, his inability to secure playoff victories remains a glaring gap in his resume.
Herbert’s career has been marked by impressive statistics, including multiple Pro Bowl appearances and consistent regular-season performances. However, his playoff record, with two losses and just two touchdowns compared to four interceptions, casts doubt on his readiness to lead LA in high-pressure moments. Critics argue that these shortcomings could limit the team’s potential despite their talent-rich roster.

The Chargers, under head coach Jim Harbaugh, made significant strides in 2024, improving to 11 wins. Yet, their postseason ended in disappointment, fueling skepticism about Herbert’s ability to elevate his performance in critical games. Analysts have cited his lack of “big-game moments” as a hurdle the team must overcome to contend in a competitive AFC West.
Despite the criticism, Herbert has shown resilience and adaptability, particularly in Harbaugh’s run-first offensive scheme. His 2024 stats, including 23 touchdowns and only three interceptions, demonstrate improved decision-making and efficiency. However, analysts remain skeptical, predicting modest numbers for 2025 and emphasizing the importance of playoff success to validate his leadership.
NFL Analysis Says Los Angeles Chargers QB Justin Herbert Main Problem is Lack of Big Game Experience

Allen’s lack of playing in big games is a big problem he has to deal with. This obstacle is detailed in an analysis by Brad Gagnon for Bleacher Report.
Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers: Big game experience
Good news is I have a feeling many big games are coming Herbert’s way. Bad news is he has two touchdowns to four interceptions in two total career playoff games, both of which were losses.
Fans and teammates continue to rally behind Herbert, recognizing his role as the face of the franchise. His leadership and potential remain undeniable, but the looming question of postseason performance weighs heavily. For Herbert and his team, the 2025 season represents a pivotal opportunity to change the narrative.

As Los Angeles aims to solidify its place among the AFC’s elite, Herbert’s ability to perform under pressure will be paramount. Overcoming the big-game hurdle is not just about individual success but about redefining the Chargers’ legacy in pursuit of a championship.

For More Of My Content
For More Of My Content Follow me on Twitter at @BeatKit22. You may also reach out to me personally at kitguinhawa@gmail.com. To read more of our articles and keep up to date on the latest in college and NFL news, click here!