The Cincinnati Bengals continue to face backlash as contract disputes with top defenders Trey Hendrickson and rookie Shemar Stewart dominate headlines. Both players have skipped offseason activities, signaling growing dissatisfaction with the team’s handling of negotiations and its broader approach to retaining key talent.
The two holdouts stem from separate issues—Trey Hendrickson is pushing for a lucrative multi-year extension following his All-Pro campaign, while rookie Shemar Stewart is reportedly frustrated with the contract’s fine print the Bengals are insisting on.
Trey Hendrickson’s contract standoff has intensified, as the veteran edge rusher publicly called out the Bengals for poor communication. After topping the league with 17.5 sacks and earning All-Pro recognition in 2024, he anticipated serious discussions about a long-term deal. So far, the front office has remained unresponsive.
On the other hand, Stewart’s rookie holdout is drawing attention for similar reasons. The first-round pick has yet to sign, reportedly due to disagreements over injury protection clauses and training camp bonuses. His absence from practice comes at a critical time, as the Bengals look to install a new defensive system.
Solving the Bengals conundrum
Both situations have reignited criticism of the Bengals’ front office, drawing attention to a pattern of contract disputes with key players. Fans and analysts alike are questioning why a team with championship aspirations is letting crucial defenders sit out over negotiable terms. The current standoffs echo past issues with players such as Jessie Bates III and DJ Reader, suggesting deeper concerns about how the organization handles its talent.
There’s likely a compromise to be found. In Hendrickson’s case, the Bengals can afford to be patient. This isn’t the first time contract tensions have surfaced with the star pass-rusher, who signed a short extension not long ago and has previously hinted at holding out. The team holds most of the leverage—unless Hendrickson is truly willing to sacrifice millions as he approaches 30.
The Stewart situation, however, offers little justification. The Bengals used a first-round pick on a pass-rusher with modest college production, making it all the more important to get him on the field quickly to begin his development.
The Bengals still have an opportunity to fix these issues. Settling on a fair rookie contract for Stewart and providing Hendrickson with a brief extension that includes guaranteed money could settle both disputes. If not, they risk weakening their defense for 2025 and further damaging the team’s reputation.
